PASS OR FAIL? It’s time to hand WVU general manager Chuck Lillie his report card! Michael Hawkins Jr., Cam Cook and DJ Epps give West Virginia plenty to celebrate—but how much credit should the roster operation receive, and where did the Mountaineers miss? Mountaineer Paul and Country Kid Jackson examine WVU’s incoming transfers and the former Mountaineers producing elsewhere. From Jahiem White’s success after leaving Morgantown to the additions tasked with rebuilding the defense, we compare production, PFF grades and playing time to ask the biggest question: Did WVU actually improve its roster? Hawkins was a massive hit. Was the rest of the class good enough? And how should responsibility be shared among Lillie, Rich Rodriguez and the coaching staff? Drop YOUR grade for Chuck Lillie in the comments—and tell us which move decided it!